Markle Foundation, Addressing Critical Public Needs in the Information Age
Site Map | Contact | FAQs | Online Privacy Policy | ©2004-2008, The Markle Foundation®
About Markle Markle Programs Resources
Who We Are
Foundation History
Frequently Asked Questions
Contact Information
Health
National Security
Program Highlights 1999-2004
Project Archives
Reports & Publications
Press Center
President's Letter
Speeches, Essays & Articles
FACCT Legacy Documents
Programs Home : Markle Programs : National Security : Projects : Project Page

National Security

Projects

MARKLE TASK FORCE ON NATIONAL SECURITY
IN THE INFORMATION AGE

March 2002 - July 2006

In the wake of the attacks of September 11th, the Markle Foundation formed the Markle Task Force on National Security in the Information Age to find ways in which information could be better used to enhance America's security while protecting our liberties. We recruited as members some of the nation's foremost authorities on national security who served in the Carter, Reagan, Bush and Clinton Administrations, as well as leading experts on information technology and civil liberties.

In October 2002, the Task Force issued its first report, Protecting America's Freedom in the Information Age, which identified the ability to share information as the most urgent task facing government in protecting the homeland. The report proposed a plan for a distributed IT network to share terrorism-related information among federal, state and local government agencies and the private sector so that threats could be identified and prevented. In addition, the report provided a framework for considering how the government might make most effective use of data residing in the private sector, while preserving liberties and avoiding the imposition of undue costs on businesses. It has had a significant impact on the debate about how to create a national security information system and was helpful to those involved in the creation of the Department of Homeland Security.

In December 2003, the Task Force released its second report, Creating A Trusted Information Network for Homeland Security. The report concluded that by using currently available technology, the government can set up a network that substantially improves our ability to prevent terrorist attacks and protect civil liberties. It provided details for the necessary elements of a proposed System-wide Homeland Analysis and Resource Exchange (SHARE) Network that would more effectively combat terrorism than our current system, while protecting privacy. The public's trust in a governmental network that makes use of information about its own people can be achieved only if government-wide guidelines for information sharing and privacy protection are established after open public debates on the issue. The Task Force therefore proposed that the President set the goal of creating such a network, and issue clear government-wide policy guidelines for the collection and use of information including private sector information.

This vision of a trusted network, along with the key attributes of our proposed Systemwide Homeland Analysis and Resource Exchange (SHARE) Network, were enacted into law in the Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004.

In July 2006, the Task Force released its third report, Mobilizing Information to Prevent Terrorism: Accelerating Development of a Trusted Information Sharing Environment. This report focuses on how to translate the vision outlined in our previous reports into reality more effectively. It recommends new concepts that serve the twin goals of improving national security and protecting privacy.

The report offers a new "authorized use" standard for government handling of legally collected information that bases authorization to view information on how the information is going to be used, rather than on the nationality of the subject or the location of collection. The report also proposes a new risk management approach to sharing classified information that balances the risk of compromising classified information with the security risk that can come from failing to share information with those who need it to understand the threats to national security. Further, the report identifies examples of technology that can be used effectively to provide appropriate oversight and accountability.

Additional Project Resources
Press Releases

July 13, 2006
Markle Task Force on National Security in the Information Age Releases Third Report, "Mobilizing Information to Prevent Terrorism: Accelerating Development of a Trusted Information Sharing Environment"

December 2, 2003
Task Force Says Government Has Not Yet Taken Advantage of America's Technology Expertise to Combate Terrorism

October 7, 2002
Markle Foundation Task Force Says FBI Should Not Be Lead Agency For Domestic Information to Prevent Terrorism

March 6, 2002
New Task Force Aims to Protect Nation with Better Information and Technology

up arrow Back to top
Reports and Publications

July 2006
Mobilizing Information to Prevent Terrorism
In July 2006, the Task Force released its third report, Mobilizing Information to Prevent Terrorism: Accelerating Development of a Trusted Information Sharing Environment. This report focuses on how to translate the vision outlined in our previous reports into reality more effectively. It recommends new concepts that serve the twin goals of improving national security and protecting privacy.

The report offers a new "authorized use" standard for government handling of legally collected information that bases authorization to view information on how the information is going to be used, rather than on the nationality of the subject or the location of collection. The report also proposes a new risk management approach to sharing classified information that balances the risk of compromising classified information with the security risk that can come from failing to share information with those who need it to understand the threats to national security. Further, the report identifies examples of technology that can be used effectively to provide appropriate oversight and accountability.

PDF icon  Download Entire Report (4.8 MB)

Download Visualization (PC, .ZIP, 72.1 MB)
Download Visualization (Macintosh, .ZIP, 50.0 MB)

Click here to download Adobe Acrobat.

up arrow Back to top

February 2006
Implementing a Trusted Information Sharing Environment
Creating a trusted information sharing environment (ISE) as envisaged by the Markle Task Force on National Security in the Information Age requires that users and the public have confidence in the system. To establish and maintain trust, security, privacy and accountability, the ISE should incorporate Immutable Audit Logs (IALS) as part of its robust security and audit features. This paper explores the technical, policy, and security issues surrounding IALs as well as the potential benefits and drawbacks of using immutable audit logs in the ISE. The paper explains how maintaining tamper-resistant logs of user activity on the network increases security, builds trust among users, ensures compliance with relevant policies and guidelines, improves transparency, and provides the ability to conduct oversight by appropriate stakeholders outside of the system.

PDF icon  Download Using Immutable Audit Logs to Increase Security, Trust and, Accountability (354K)

Click here to download Adobe Acrobat.

up arrow Back to top

December 2003
Creating a Trusted Information Network for Homeland Security
In December 2003, the Task Force released its second report, Creating A Trusted Information Network for Homeland Security. The report concluded that by using currently available technology, the government can set up a network that substantially improves our ability to prevent terrorist attacks and protect civil liberties. It provided details for the necessary elements of a proposed System-wide Homeland Analysis and Resource Exchange (SHARE) Network that would more effectively combat terrorism than our current system, while protecting privacy.

The public's trust in a governmental network that makes use of information about its own people can be achieved only if government-wide guidelines for information sharing and privacy protection are established after open public debates on the issue. The Task Force therefore proposed that the President set the goal of creating such a network, and issue clear government-wide policy guidelines for the collection and use of information about people in the U.S., including private sector information.

PDF icon  Download Entire Report (1MB)
PDF icon  Download Table of Contents (76K)
PDF icon  Download Overview (36K)
PDF icon  Download Part I (352K)
PDF icon  Download Part II (149K)
PDF icon  Download Part III (621K)
PDF icon  Download 2003 Members Guide (487K)

Download Visualization (PC, .ZIP, 24.7 MB)
Download Visualization (Macintosh, .ZIP, 25.0 MB)

Go to Matrices of Laws Governing Governmental and Commercial Access to Privately Held Data

Click here to download Adobe Acrobat.

up arrow Back to top

October 2002
Protecting America's Freedom in the Information Age
In October 2002, the Task Force issued its first report, Protecting America's Freedom in the Information Age, which identified the ability to share information as the most urgent task facing government in protecting the homeland. The report proposed a plan for a distributed IT network to share terrorism-related information among federal, state and local government agencies and the private sector so that threats could be identified and prevented. In addition, the report provided a framework for considering how the government might make most effective use of data residing in the private sector, while preserving liberties and avoiding the imposition of undue costs on businesses. It has had a significant impact on the debate about how to create a national security information system and was helpful to those involved in the creation of the Department of Homeland Security.

PDF icon  Download Entire Report (971K)

PDF icon  Part I - The Task Force Report (324K)

PDF icon  Part II - Working Group Analyses (195K)

PDF icon  Part III - Selected Background Research (453K)

Go to excerpts from the Report Overview

Click here to download Adobe Acrobat.

up arrow Back to top

Image of US Constitution
Members & Associates
2006 Task Force Members & Assoiates
Related Websites
markletaskforce.org
Reports and Publications
Mobilizing Information to Prevent Terrorism

Mobilizing Information to Prevent Terrorism
Implementing a Trusted Information Sharing Environment

Implementing a Trusted Information Sharing Environment
Creating a Trusted Information Network for Homeland Security

Creating a Trusted Network for Homeland Security
Protecting America's Freedom in the Information Age

Protecting America's Freedom in the Information Age
Additional Resources
(Advanced Search)
Quick Reference:
About Markle Who We Are | Foundation History | Frequently Asked Questions | Contact Information
Markle Programs Health | National Security | Program Highlights 1999-2004 | Project Archive
Resources Reports & Publications | Press Center | President's Letter | Speeches, Essays & Articles
FACCT Legacy Documents